AFTER THE INJUNCTION: THE ROLE OF THE COURTS IN POLICING INDIGENOUS RESISTANCE IN B.C.
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.63315/cjnsoa.v42i1.2906Abstract
Indigenous land defenders challenging major projects on traditional territory remains an enduring feature of Canadian politics. These projects can be protected by court-issued injunctions that can authorize the state to dispel land defenders. Although there is a growing body of scholarship that shows how injunctions are typically granted to favour businesses and the state (Pasternak and Ceric, 2023), the sentencing of individuals who violate injunctions is underexplored. We analyze the sentencing decisions of Indigenous individuals who violated injunctions protecting three major projects in B.C.: the Coastal GasLink pipeline, logging at the Fairy Creek watershed, and the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion. We find that in the total eight sentencing decisions across these projects, the court typically does not accept the defendants’ arguments that commitment to Indigenous laws that protect traditional territory are relevant background factors that should mitigate against incarceration. Thus, Gladue principles are considered during sentencing, but our analysis suggests that Gladue does not live up to its promise of requiring courts to appreciate Indigenous laws, culture, and heritage.
References
Bargh, Maria. (2007). Introduction to Resistance: An Indigenous Response to Neoliberalism, ed. Maria Bargh. Wellington, NZ: Huia Publishers.
Bellrichard, Chantelle. (2020). “No criminal charges for people arrested during injunction enforcement on Wet’suwet’en territory,” CBC News, June 5.
Borrows, John. (2005). Crown and Aboriginal Occupations of Land: A History & Comparison. Toronto: Ipperwash Inquiry
Briggs, Jacqueline. (2020). Mercy redux: A genealogy of special consideration of Indigenous circumstances at sentencing in Canada, from Indian Agents to Gladue and Ipeelee. Studies in Law, Politics, and Society, 83, 57-97.
CBC News. (2018). “Federal Green Party Leader Elizabeth May arrested at anti-pipeline protest,” CBC News, March 23, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/anti-pipelineprotest-elizabeth-may-kennedy-stewart-1.4587631.
CBC News. (2018b). “19 arrested at Trans Mountain pipeline protest site in Burnaby, B.C.,”
CBC News, March 19, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/19-arrested-at-transmountain-pipeline-protest-site-in-burnaby-b-c-1.4583138.
CBC News. (2019). “People arrested at Gidimt’en anti-pipeline camp allege inappropriate use of force,” CBC News, January 12.
CBC News. (2021). “First Nation’s council and chief ask ‘3rd-party’ activists to stand down in B.C. logging dispute,” CBC News, April 13, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/britishcolumbia/bc-fairy-creek-pacheedaht-first-nation-1.5986420
Chartrand, Vicki. (2019). “Unsettled Times: Indigenous Incarceration and the Links between Colonialism and the Penitentiary in Canada.” Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 61(3), 67–89.
Coastal GasLink. (2023). “About Coastal GasLink” https://www.coastalgaslink.com/about/ last accessed: 16 July 2024
Corrigall-Brown, Catherine and Wilkes, Rima. (2012). “Picturing Protest: The Visual Framing of Collective Action by First Nations Canada.” American Behavioral Science, 56(2), 223–243.
Coulthard, Glen Sean. (2014). Red Skin, White Masks: Rejecting the Colonial Politics of Recognition. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Crosby, Andrew and Monaghan, Jeffrey. (2018). Policing Indigenous Movements: Dissent and the Security State. Winnipeg: Fernwood.
Crosby, Andrew. (2021). The racialized logics of settler colonial policing: Indigenous ‘communities of concern’ and critical infrastructure in Canada, Settler Colonial Studies, 11(4), 411-430.
Dafnos, Tia. (2013). Pacification and Indigenous Struggles in Canada. Socialist Studies, 9(2), 5777.
Dalton, Sarah. (2022). Our land, our way: The rule of law, injunctions, and Indigenous selfgovernance. UNB Law Journal 73, 312-337.
Denis-Boileau, Marie-Andrée. (2021). The Gladue Analysis: Shedding Light on Appropriate Sentencing Procedures and Sanctions. UBC Law Review, 54(3), 537-628.
Do, Minh. (2020). Throughput Legitimacy and the Duty to Consult: The Limits of the Law to Produce Quality Interactions in British Columbia’s EA Process. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 53(3), 577-595.
Do, Minh. (2023). Salient Indigenous Acts of Resistance in Canada, 2010–2020: Current Trends. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 56(4), 936–949.
Government of British Columbia. (2020). “Wet’suwet’en, B.C. and Canada launch path to implement rights and title,” B.C. Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation News Release: https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2020IRR0008000883#:~:text=The%20MOU%20commits%20Wet'suwet,Delgamuukw%2DGisday'wa% 20ruling last accessed: 16 July 2024.
Government of British Columbia. (2021). “Premier’s statement on Hišuk ma c’awak Declaration, deferral request,” Office of the Premier News Release, https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2021PREM0041-001101
Government of British Columbia. (2024). “Old growth deferral areas,” https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/industry/forestry/managing-our-forest-resources/oldgrowth-forests/deferral-areas
Government of Canada. (2020). “Memorandum of Understanding between Canada, British Columbia and Wet’suwet’en as agreed on February 29, 2020,” Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada, https://www.rcaanccirnac.gc.ca/eng/1589478905863/1589478945624 last accessed: 16 July 2024.
Gunn, Kate. (2020). Injunctions as a tool of colonialism. First Peoples Law (blog): https://www.firstpeopleslaw.com/public-education/blog/injunctions-as-a-tool-of-colonialism (last accessed 30 May 2024).
Hamilton, A. C., and Sinclair, M. (1991). Report of the Aboriginal Justice Inquiry of Manitoba. Government of Manitoba. [Aboriginal Justice Inquiry]
Hamilton, Robert and Joshua Nichols. (2019). The Tin Ear of the Court: Ktunaxa Nation and the Foundation of the Duty to Consult. Alberta Law Review, 56(3), 729-760.
Harb, Jenna, Henne, Kathryn. (2019). Disinformation and resistance in the surveillance of Indigenous protesters. Information, technology and control in a changing world: Understanding power structures in the 21st century, 187-211.
Hedican, Edward. (2008). The Ipperwash Inquiry and the tragic death of Dudley George. Canadian Journal of Native Studies 28(1), 159-173.
Hedican, Edward. (2012). Policing Aboriginal protests and confrontations: Some policy recommendations. The International Indigenous Policy Journal, 3(2), 1-17
Hume, Rebecca, Walby, Kevin. (2021). Framing, suppression, and colonial policing redux in Canada: News representations of the 2019 Wet’suwet’en blockade. Journal of Canadian studies, 55(3), 507-540.
Hunter, Justine, and Mychaylo Prystupa. (2017). “Weigh Anchor,” The Globe and Mail, https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/kinder-morgan-trans-mountainpipeline-bc-coast/article35043172/
Kathleen Harris, Kathleen. (2018). “Liberals to buy Trans Mountain pipeline for $4.5B to ensure expansion is built,” CBC News, May 29, https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/liberals-transmountain-pipeline-kinder-morgan-1.4681911.
Kieran Oudshoorn, Kieran. (2023). “The Fallout of Fairy Creek,” CBC News, June 21, https://www.cbc.ca/radiointeractives/features/the-fallout-of-fairy-creek.
Ladner, Keira, and Simpson, Leanne Betasamosake (eds.). (2010). This is an Honour Song: Twenty Years Since the Blockades, an Anthology of Writing on the" Oka Crisis". Winnipeg: Arbeiter Ring Publishing. disobedience
Larsen, Karin. (2021). “Fairy Creek protest on Vancouver Island now considered largest act of civil in Canadian history,” CBC News, September 9. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/fairy-creek-protest-largest-act-of-civildisobedience-1.6168210.
Mayeda, Graham. (2010). Access to justice: The impact of injunctions, contempt of court proceedings, and costs awards on environmental protestors and First Nations. McGill International Journal of Sustainable Development, Law and Policy, 6, 143-176.
Morden, Michael. (2013). “Telling Stories about Conflict: Symbolic Politics and the Ipperwash Land Transfer Agreement.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 46(3): 505–24.
Morin, Brandi. (2017). “Activists in B.C. gear up for ‘the next Standing Rock’ with tiny house protest,” CBC News, September 7, https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/kinder-morganpipeline-activists-tiny-houses-1.4279740.
Mussell, Linda. (2023). Decolonizing Research on the Carceral in Canadian Political Science. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 56(3), 571–595.
Newell, Ryan. (2012). Only one law: Indigenous land disputes and the contested nature of the rule of law. Indigenous Law Journal 11(1), 41-72
Office of the Wet’suwet’en. (n.d.). “Our Mission” http://www.wetsuweten.com/office/ourmission/ last accessed: 16 July 2024.
Old Growth Forest Ecology. (2024). “Fairy Creek,” https://oldgrowthforestecology.org/fairycreek/ last accessed: 16 July 2024.
Pasternak, Shiri and Ceric, Irina. (2023). 'The Legal Billy Club': First Nations, Injunctions, and the Public Interest. Toronto Metropolitan University Law Review, 1, 7-31.
Patten, Chris. (1999). A new beginning: Policing in Northern Ireland, the report of the Independent Commission on Policing for Northern Ireland. Norwich: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
Pawson, Chad, (2017). “Hundreds Rally in Burnaby to oppose Trans Mountain pipeline expansion,” CBC News, May 28, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/4-dayanti-kinder-morgan-march-1.4135412.
Pawson, Chad, (2018). “Pipeline protesters predict number of arrests over Trans Mountain will eclipse War in the Woods,” CBC News, July 16, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/britishcolumbia/trans-mountain-pipeline-expansion-arrests-1.4747601.
Perzyna, Maggie and Bauder, Harald. (2022). Threats from within and threats from without: Wet’suwet’en protesters, irregular asylum seekers and on-going settler colonialism in Canada. Settler Colonial Studies, 13(1), 71–95.
Rudin, Jonathan. (2008). Aboriginal over-representation and R v. Gladue: Where we were, where we are and where we might be going. Supreme Court Law Review 40(2d), 687-713.
Rudin, Jonathan. (2012). Looking backward, looking forward: The Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in R v. Ipeelee. Supreme Court Law Review, 57(2d), 375-388.
Russell, Peter. (2010). “Oka to Ipperwash: The Necessity of Flashpoint Events.” In This Is an Honour Song: Twenty Years since the Blockades, an Anthology of Writing on the" Oka Crisis", ed. Ladner, Kiera and Simpson, Leanne Betasamosake. Winnipeg: Arbeiter Ring Press
Rythoven, Eric. (2021). A feeling of unease: Distance, emotion, and securitizing Indigenous protest in Canada, International Political Sociology 15, 251-271.
Simpson, Leanne Betasamosake. (2021). A Short History of the Blockade: Giant Beavers, Diplomacy, and Regeneration of Nishnaabewin. Alberta: University of Alberta Press.
Smith, Tonya and Janette Bulkan. (2021). A ‘New Relationship’? Reflections on British Columbia’s 2003 Forest Revitalization Plan from the Perspective of the Lilwat First Nation. Land Use Policy, 105, 1-13.
Stark, Heidi Kiiwetinepinesiik, Craft, Aimée and Aikau, Hokulani K. (eds.) (2023). Indigenous Resurgence in an Age of Reconciliation. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Stark, Heidi Kiiwetinepinesiik. (2016). “Criminal Empire: The Making of the Savage in a Lawless Land.” Theory & Event 19(4)
Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. (2015). Honouring the truth, reconciling for the future. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Minh Do, Ph.D. , Kate Puddister, Ph.D.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
This license enables reusers to copy and distribute the material in any medium or format in unadapted form only, for noncommercial purposes only, and only so long as attribution is given to the creator. CC BY-NC-ND includes the following elements:
BY: credit must be given to the creator.
NC: Only noncommercial uses of the work are permitted.
ND: No derivatives or adaptations of the work are permitted.
